Open Source Windows service for reporting server load back to HAProxy (load balancer feedback agent).

In general when you are load balancing a cluster you can evenly spread the connections through the cluster and you get pretty consistent and even load balancing. However with some applications such as RDS (Microsoft Terminal Servers), you can get very high load from just a  few users doing heavy work. The solution to this is to use some kind of server load feedback agent. We’ve had one of these for a while in our product but now with a lot of help from Simon Horman we’ve managed to integrate the functionality into the main branch (well soon anyway) of HAproxy. We thought it would be a good idea to open source the previous work on Ldirectord/LVS, make it compatible with HAProxy, and release our Windows service code as GPL.

Until the work is merged and tested with an official release of HAProxy we’ve compiled a patched version of HAProxy dev19 ish here…. (http://downloads.loadbalancer.org/agent/haproxy-agent-check-20130813.tar.gz) Or you can get the patches from the mailing list archive…

UPDATE: The Loadbalancer.org feedback agent code is now supported in HAProxy 1.5-dev21

Download the Windows Feedback Agent Service Here:  http://downloads.loadbalancer.org/agent/loadbalanceragent.msi

 

Simply compile as usual and then modify your RDS cluster:

listen RDSTest
	bind 192.168.69.22:3389
	mode tcp
	balance leastconn
	persist rdp-cookie
	server backup 127.0.0.1:9081 backup  non-stick
	tcp-request inspect-delay 5s
	tcp-request content accept if RDP_COOKIE
	timeout client 12h
	timeout server 12h
	option tcpka
	option redispatch
	option abortonclose
	maxconn 40000
	server Win2008R2 192.168.64.50:3389 weight 100 check agent-check agent-port 3333 inter 2000  rise 2  fall 3 minconn 0  maxconn 0  on-marked-down shutdown-sessions

The important bit agent-check agent-port 3333 tells HAProxy to constantly monitor each backend server in the cluster by doing a telnet to port 3333 and grabbing the response which will usually be a percentage idle value i.e.

80% – I am not very busy please increase my weight and send me more traffic
10% – I’m busy please decrease my weight and stop sending me so much traffic
drain – Set the weight to 0 and gradually drain the traffic from this server for maintenance
stop – Stop all traffic immediately, kill this backend server

If you have a Linux backend you could create a simple service calling the following script:

#!/bin/bash
LOAD=(/usr/bin/vmstat 1 2| /usr/bin/tail -1| /usr/bin/awk '{print $15;}' | /usr/bin/tee)
echo "$LOAD%"
#This outputs a 1 second average CPU idle

Call the script  /usr/bin/lb-feedback.sh
make sure that you make it executable:

chmod +x /usr/bin/lb-feedback.sh


Insert this line into /etc/services

lb-feedback 3333/tcp # loadbalancer.org feedback daemon

Now create the following file called /etc/xinetd.d/lb-feedback

# default: on
# description: lb-feedback socket server
service lb-feedback
{
 port = 3333
 socket_type = stream
 flags = REUSE
 wait = no
 user = nobody
 server = /usr/bin/lb-feedback.sh
 log_on_success += USERID
 log_on_failure += USERID
 disable = no
}

Then change permissions and restart xinetd:

chmod 644 /etc/xinetd.d/lb-feedback
/etc/init.d/xinetd restart

You can now test this service by using telnet:

telnet 127.0.0.1 3333
Trying 127.0.0.1...
Connected to 127.0.0.1.
Escape character is '^]'.
95%
Connection closed by foreign host.

Now if you have a Windows server as your backend you can use our open source monitor service. You can download the Loadbalancer.org windows feedback agent here (http://downloads.loadbalancer.org/agent/loadbalanceragent.msi)

Source code is here together with the binary: CpuMonitor_4.3.0.zip

Once you have installed Loadbalancer.org feedback service you should find the monitor.exe file in Program Files/LoadBalancer.org

Feedback

Simply hit the ‘start’ button and the agent should start responding to telnet on port 3333 (you may need to make an exception for that port in your Windows firewall).

You can change the ‘mode’ setting to drain then ‘apply settings and restart’ and HAProxy will then set the weight to 0 and status to drain (blue) i.e.:

drain

Or you can set the ‘mode’ to halt then ‘apply settings and restart’ and HAProxy will then immediately set the status to DOWN (yellow) i.e.:

down

When the agent is running in normal mode it will report back the percentage idle of the system based on the settings in the feedback agent XML file:

<xml>
  <Cpu>
    <ImportanceFactor value="1" />
    <ThresholdValue value="100" />
  </Cpu>
  <Ram>
    <ImportanceFactor value="0" />
    <ThresholdValue value="100" />
  </Ram>
  <TCPService>
    <Name value="HTTP" />
    <IPAddress value="*" />
    <Port value="80" />
    <MaxConnections value="0" />
    <ImportanceFactor value="0" />
  </TCPService>
  <ReadAgentStatusFromConfig value="False" />
  <ReadAgentStatusFromConfigInterval value="5" />
  <AgentStatus value="Normal" />
</xml>

Notice that you can control both the importance of CPU & RAM utilization and also a threshold, so the following logic is used:

If CPU importance = 0 then ignore
If RAM importance = 0 then ignore
If Threshold level is reached on any monitor then immediately go into DRAIN mode.

Otherwise to calculate the percentage idle reported by the agent we
would be to divide the utilization by the number of factors involved i.e.

If you are using two services then:

utilization = utilization + cpuLoad * cpuImportance%;
utilization = utilization + ramOccupied * ramImportance%;
utilization = utilization / 2

So if importance was 1 for both cpu and ram you would only get 0% reported if both CPU and RAM were 100%.

And if the importance is zero then ignore completely i.e.

utilization = utilization + cpuLoad * cpuImportance%;
//utilization = utilization + ramOccupied * 0 (importance is zero so ignore)
utilization = utilization (one service only so don’t divide)

Also the final section TCPService effictvley lets you load balance on number of established connections to your server, so you could balance based on the number of RDP connections to port 3389.

For this setting MaxConnections is important to specify as otherwise the agent will have no idea how to calculate the load i.e.
utilization = MaxConnections / 100 * number of current connections * importance%

In the following screen shot from a Loadbalancer.org appliance you can see that the Win2008R2 server is healthy and 99% idle, whereas the Linux server was busy at 43% idle before the Linux agent was put into maintenance mode and the server taken out of the group.

sysoverview

Does that make sense? Have a play with the config file and let us know what you think….

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

21 thoughts on “Open Source Windows service for reporting server load back to HAProxy (load balancer feedback agent).

  1. Felix,
    Full support for the new agent will be incorporated in the Loadbalancer.org ENTERPRISE VA v7.6. The new version will also include external health check scripts, ssl re-encryption etc. I’ll update this post as soon as we have a release date (which should be very soon).

  2. Hi,

    We currently testing with this custom version of HAProxy. The backend servers are multiple Windows 2008R2 server with the loadbalancer.org agent.

    The problem is that the weight value is not decreased during heavy load. The agent is reporting the correct value. Please could someone help me to fix this problem? My config file:

    global
    daemon
    stats socket /var/run/haproxy.stat mode 600 level admin
    pidfile /var/run/haproxy.pid
    maxconn 40000
    ulimit-n 81000
    tune.maxrewrite 1024
    defaults
    mode http
    balance roundrobin
    timeout connect 4000
    timeout client 42000
    timeout server 43000
    listen RDP_Test
    bind 172.17.20.8:3389
    mode tcp
    balance leastconn
    option tcpka
    tcp-request inspect-delay 5s
    tcp-request content accept if RDP_COOKIE
    option tcpka
    timeout client 12h
    timeout server 12h
    option redispatch
    option abortonclose
    maxconn 40000
    server SRV-TS01 172.17.20.5:3389 weight 100 check agent-port 3333 inter 2000 rise 2 fall 3 minconn 0 maxconn 0 on-marked-down shutdown-sessions
    server SRV-TS02 172.17.20.6:3389 weight 100 check agent-port 3333 inter 2000 rise 2 fall 3 minconn 0 maxconn 0 on-marked-down shutdown-sessions
    server SRV-TS03 172.17.20.7:3389 weight 100 check agent-port 3333 inter 2000 rise 2 fall 3 minconn 0 maxconn 0 on-marked-down shutdown-sessions
    listen stats :7777
    stats enable
    stats uri /
    option httpclose
    stats auth loadbalancer:loadbalancer

    Thanks!

  3. Hi there,

    I was looking for something about HAProxy and found that post, and it’s funny because we already worked on this topic. We’ve developed such a feature in the past year for HAProxy, relying the http check “disbale-on-404″ feature. In fact, we have a light service (.NET service with listening socket) that will return 200 if load is OK, 404 if not. The load trigger is fully configurable, could be base on CPU load, RAM load or both. The period on wich the load is monitored is also configurable and all settings are stored in the regsitry to permit configuration deployement through GPO. When the load is ok, the returned page also contains the actual load of the server.

  4. Willem,

    Could you provide some more detail?
    Do the weights in HAProxy change correctly under normal load?
    Is it when the real server is under high load only that the problem occurs?

  5. I’m using Feedback Agent 4.3.0 for Windows with HAProxy 1.5.3, there is an issue.

    When I set agent status from NORMAL to DOWN/DRAIN, HAProxy stats then marked this server as DOWN/DRAIN forever, even though later I set agent back to NORMAL and restart agent service, but the server still marked as DOWN/DRAIN in HAProxy stats. Unless I do a HAProxy reload, then the server back to NORMAL in HAProxy stats.

  6. Ken,

    The behaviour of the various drain modes in HAProxy has been improved recently, unfortunately our Windows agent needs a change to be compatible.

    It needs to report something like:
    “up ready 100%” after it comes out of drain mode (for 60 seconds or so…)

    Our dev team just started looking into this very issue last week.They will make a decision on the best way to change the windows agent to be compatible with the new HAProxy implementation of the agent in the next couple of days.

    (taken from the email to the haproxy
    mailing list ‘health check hell’ – ”
    “up” : declare the server up, don’t change the configured weight
    “up 50%” : declare the server up, set weight to 50%
    “50%” : don’t touch the server state, just set the weight to 50%
    “drain” : don’t touch the state, nor weight, just switch to drain mode.
    “maint” : force maintenance mode.
    “drain 20%” : drain mode, adjust weight to 20% (not used in this mode but
    will avoid complex logics in agent scripts)
    “ready 30%” : leave maint/drain modes, start at 30% weight.
    “up ready 40%” : the agent does the 3 things at once and says the
    service is OK.
    “stopped drain 10%” : the agent does the 3 things at once and
    indicates that the server is now down after drain mode.”

  7. Hi,

    does it support virtual host on Xenserver? I have noticed that the weights in HAProxy change correctly on physical server but are static on virtual host. I have done some digging and the agent does not send any data on a virtual machine?

    Many thanks
    Ys

  8. Hi,

    Me2 but it just doesn’t work. The firewall is disabled and the only difference between the two servers is physical vs virtual. I am sure there is something wrong because on physical server I can see plenty connections to HAproxy and on virtual just one that disappears after 2 seconds. Also, when I use process explorer to see what is actually going on. On Physical, I can see connection, then loadbalancer agent reading the data, stooping and sending where on virtual it gets to reading the data and then it does not send just quits.. Very bizarre. I recon it may be something with virtual adapter but was wondering if you can have more insight on this.

    Thanks

  9. I have installed and configured the loadbalancer agent on two additional servers. Same as before, one physical and one virtual. Outcome is the same. Now, two physical are working perfectly fine where virtual are not. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.

    Thanks

  10. Hi Malcolm, details about the version below.

    BUILD_NUMBER=’59235p’
    PRODUCT_BRAND=’XenServer’
    PRODUCT_VERSION_TEXT_SHORT=’6.1′
    COMPANY_NAME_SHORT=’Citrix’
    PLATFORM_NAME=’XCP’
    PLATFORM_VERSION=’1.6.10′
    KERNEL_VERSION=’2.6.32.43-0.4.1.xs1.6.10.734.170748xen’
    BRAND_CONSOLE=’XenCenter’
    COMPANY_NAME=’Citrix Systems, Inc.’
    XEN_VERSION=’4.1.3′
    PRODUCT_VERSION_TEXT=’6.1′
    MANAGEMENT_ADDRESS_TYPE=’IPv4′
    PRODUCT_NAME=’xenenterprise’
    PRODUCT_VERSION=’6.1.0′
    INSTALLATION_DATE=’2013-03-22 11:56:01.977608′

    The only agents installed is XenAgent and PHD Virtual Backup Agent. Windows version 2008 R2 with all the updates, role Terminal Server. Firewall (build-in) is disabled, antivirus disabled (sophos).

    Regards,
    Ys

    • Ys,

      We had another user complaining about the agent failing on a virtual host, we are just doing some testing relating to how fast the agent can get a response about CPU speed in a virtual host and we shall let you know asap.

    • Ys,

      We think we have found a potential problem where HAProxy is giving up on waiting for the response (the default timeout for agent check is 2 seconds).
      Could you try the following global setting:
      timeout check 5s
      and potentially the backend setting
      agent check 5s
      And restart the agent + haproxy?

Leave a Reply

Login with your Social ID

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Powered by sweet Captcha